名稱冠有合氣卻不討論合氣,是逃避主要課題。
合氣是什麼?如同之前所述,是類似關閉對手反抗機制的技術,讓對手沒有抗力點可能是其一,透過下半身的強壯而不給予接觸點壓力可能也是其一,透過全身結構施展技術可能也是其一,根據佐川幸義的說法,合氣不需要力氣才能發揮真正的力,甚至不需要用到腰臀也不用身體,但前提卻是要不斷地鍛鍊身體,看似矛盾但有合理的解釋。
討論上面的解釋之前,或許會問,那麼合氣具體是什麼?或許一開始這樣的命題就不正確,或許應該是問「合氣的感覺是什麼?」以及「什麼不是合氣?」,透過追尋正確的感覺以及否定錯誤的方式,透過不斷地逼近法求取近似值,就像求取無理數π一樣,當無限逼近求值時,就會無限接近π,在追尋合氣的感覺時,反推有可能強化合氣的鍛鍊法,看似矛盾但或許是最能夠實踐的方式;感覺既是追尋合氣技術最真實的線索,也是最容易自我欺騙的幻影,所以需要透過不斷否定跟置疑來打磨技術。
那麼「合氣的感覺是什麼?」目前說法是欺騙對手的反射感官(或說是關掉對手的抵抗機制),欺騙對手的反射感官在於,當取方一旦開始動,受方就找不到任何可以回推的抵抗點,具體做法透過身體移動、支點滑動、支點鬆脫等方式達成,之所以難以確認具體做法的原因在於透過長期訓練讓身體自主完成一系列動作,一旦頭腦介入太多(軟體過載)就會讓身體運行遲滯(硬體無法執行)而無法綿密且連續完成技術,所以即便感覺難以捉摸但卻是通往合氣的必要挑戰。
回到上面的解釋:「合氣不需要力量也不需要依靠身體,但不鍛鍊身體是無法逼近練成合氣技術」,這句話的合理處在於,合氣確實不是光靠力量跟身體能夠實現,但沒有鍛鍊的身體只能偶然使出合氣,而不能掌控合氣。
“『合氣並非與宇宙合一,或用愛包容一切那種抽象的東西。而是確實的技術。火箭能登上月球,也是因為按照一定的理論去執行才能成功。要擊倒人,也是有理論的。』這是老師的持論。」
老師說:「我是依循理論來擊倒對方的。不是靠力量。我不採納那種靠氣或神明而產生無限力量的想法。”
“以為合氣不是力量,所以不鍛鍊身體也能練成合氣,那是大錯特錯。這不是只靠頭腦或精神就能做到的。不過,即使懂了合氣,要強化它的鍛鍊法也很難明白。 這是我自己想出來的。合氣不像大家想的那麼簡單。 它非常細微、精妙,而且複雜。」
出自 -深淵の色は 佐川幸義伝- 津本 陽
If a discipline bears the name "Aiki" yet does not address the topic of Aiki itself, it is evading the central issue.
So, what is Aiki? As previously discussed, it is a technique that effectively neutralizes an opponent’s resistance. This might involve eliminating any point at which the opponent can apply force, using a strong lower body to avoid exerting pressure at the physical point of contact, or performing techniques through coordinated use of the whole body’s structure. According to Yukiyoshi Sagawa, the true power of Aiki manifests not through brute strength, nor even through conscious use of the hips or body; yet, paradoxically, developing this power requires relentless training of the body. Though this may seem contradictory, it is, in fact, quite reasonable.
Before delving further, one might ask, "What, precisely, is Aiki?" But perhaps this question itself is misguided. Instead, we should ask: "What does Aiki feel like?” and “What is not Aiki?" By seeking out the correct sensation and rejecting the erroneous, by progressively narrowing in on the essence—much like approximating the irrational number π—we can draw ever closer to an accurate understanding. Through this process of infinite approximation, our sense of Aiki can become more refined; paradoxically, the process of seeking the feeling may in fact reveal the very methods best suited for training Aiki. Although this seems contradictory, it may prove the most practical path. Sensation is both the truest clue to the technique of Aiki and, simultaneously, the most treacherous illusion—it is easy to deceive oneself. Therefore, continuous self-doubt and rigorous questioning are essential for polishing one’s technique.
So, “what is the feeling of Aiki?” The current explanation is that it deceives the opponent’s reflexive senses (or, in other words, shuts down the opponent’s resistance mechanism). Deceiving the opponent’s reflexive senses means that once the tori (the one executing the technique) begins to move, the uke (the one receiving) cannot find any point to push back against. The concrete method is achieved through body movement, pivot sliding, pivot release, and similar means. The reason it is difficult to pinpoint the exact method lies in the fact that, through long-term training, the body autonomously executes a series of actions. Once the mind intervenes too much (software overload), it causes the body to slow down (hardware cannot execute), preventing the technique from being carried out with continuity and precision. Therefore, even though the sensation is elusive, it is nonetheless a necessary challenge on the path to Aiki.
Reconsider the earlier statement: “Aiki does not require physical strength, nor does it rely on the body, yet without rigorous bodily training, mastery of Aiki techniques is impossible.” The logic here is clear: Aiki does not emerge solely from strength or the body, but without persistent training, one may stumble upon the essence of Aiki only by chance, never reliably controlling it. This, at present, seems the most plausible interpretation.
Sagawa Sensei once remarked: “Aiki is not about uniting with the universe, nor is it a vague notion of embracing everything with love—it is a precise technique. Just as rockets reach the moon by adhering to exact scientific theory, overcoming an opponent also depends on sound principles." Sensei stressed: “I defeat opponents by applying theory, not force. I do not subscribe to the concept of limitless strength drawn from 'ki' or any divine source.”
“To believe that Aiki can be developed without training the body, simply because it is not about raw power, is a grave mistake. One cannot achieve it by intellect or spirit alone. Yet, even upon grasping the essence of Aiki, understanding how to strengthen it through training remains elusive—I had to figure it out for myself. Aiki is far from simple; it is subtle, intricate, and deeply complex.”
- “The Color of the Abyss: The Biography of Yukiyoshi Sagawa" by Akira Tsumoto